QuestionJune 12, 2025

How has the state of Texas used Of Mice and Men to determine a person's criminal culpability? What argument does Steinbeck's son make against the court's use of his father's book? Provide specific evidence from "Supreme Court Denies Execution" and Thomas Steinbeck's statement on the Marvin Williams case to support your answer. __

How has the state of Texas used Of Mice and Men to determine a person's criminal culpability? What argument does Steinbeck's son make against the court's use of his father's book? Provide specific evidence from "Supreme Court Denies Execution" and Thomas Steinbeck's statement on the Marvin Williams case to support your answer. __
How has the state of Texas used Of Mice and Men to determine a person's criminal culpability?
What argument does Steinbeck's son make against the court's use of his father's book? Provide
specific evidence from "Supreme Court Denies Execution" and Thomas Steinbeck's statement on
the Marvin Williams case to support your answer.
__

Solution
4.1(216 votes)

Answer

In Texas, "Of Mice and Men" has been used in court cases to assess criminal culpability by suggesting that characters like Lennie demonstrate diminished responsibility due to mental incapacity. In "Supreme Court Denies Execution," it is highlighted how courts have drawn parallels between fictional characters and real-life defendants. Thomas Steinbeck contends that using his father’s novel in such a manner distorts its message about human dignity and moral complexity. He emphasizes that Lennie's tragic fate should not be simplified into legal arguments but rather understood as a commentary on society's treatment of vulnerable individuals. Explanation The state of Texas has referenced "Of Mice and Men" to argue that individuals with intellectual disabilities, like the character Lennie, may not fully understand their actions, impacting their culpability. Thomas Steinbeck argues against this interpretation, stating it misrepresents his father's work and its themes.

Explanation

The state of Texas has referenced "Of Mice and Men" to argue that individuals with intellectual disabilities, like the character Lennie, may not fully understand their actions, impacting their culpability. Thomas Steinbeck argues against this interpretation, stating it misrepresents his father's work and its themes.
Click to rate:

Similar Questions