QuestionMay 23, 2025

Prompt 2 - Argumentative: In the beginning of the novel, Major claims that humans are the animals only real enemy. Do you agree? Who or what is the real enemy of the animals? Provide text evidence to support your argument.

Prompt 2 - Argumentative: In the beginning of the novel, Major claims that humans are the animals only real enemy. Do you agree? Who or what is the real enemy of the animals? Provide text evidence to support your argument.
Prompt 2 - Argumentative: In the beginning of the novel, Major claims that humans are the animals only
real enemy. Do you agree? Who or what is the real enemy of the animals? Provide text evidence to support
your argument.

Solution
4.7(117 votes)

Answer

I agree with Major's claim that humans are the primary enemy of animals, as they exploit them for labor, food, and entertainment. For instance, in Chapter 1, Major describes how humans take advantage of animal labor without giving anything in return, emphasizing the inherent injustice. Additionally, the apathy and lack of unity among animals further exacerbate their suffering, suggesting that while humans are the direct oppressors, the animals' own divisions and ignorance act as a secondary enemy. This duality underscores the complexity of their struggle for liberation. Explanation In the context of the novel, Major's assertion highlights the exploitation and oppression faced by animals at the hands of humans. However, one could argue that ignorance and complacency among animals themselves also serve as significant enemies. Text evidence can illustrate how both external (humans) and internal (animal behavior) factors contribute to their plight.

Explanation

In the context of the novel, Major's assertion highlights the exploitation and oppression faced by animals at the hands of humans. However, one could argue that ignorance and complacency among animals themselves also serve as significant enemies. Text evidence can illustrate how both external (humans) and internal (animal behavior) factors contribute to their plight.
Click to rate:

Similar Questions