QuestionJune 27, 2025

Which fallacy does the following argument commit? All musicians are players All Sousaphonists are musicians Therefore All Sousaphonists are players Undistributed Middle Illicit major/illicit minor Two negative premises Negative premise/affirmative conclusion, Negative conclusion/affirmative premises The existential fallacy No fallacy: this one's valid

Which fallacy does the following argument commit? All musicians are players All Sousaphonists are musicians Therefore All Sousaphonists are players Undistributed Middle Illicit major/illicit minor Two negative premises Negative premise/affirmative conclusion, Negative conclusion/affirmative premises The existential fallacy No fallacy: this one's valid
Which fallacy does the following argument commit?
All musicians are players
All Sousaphonists are musicians
Therefore All Sousaphonists are players
Undistributed Middle
Illicit major/illicit minor
Two negative premises
Negative premise/affirmative conclusion, Negative conclusion/affirmative premises
The existential fallacy
No fallacy: this one's valid

Solution
4.1(338 votes)

Answer

Undistributed Middle Explanation The argument commits the "Undistributed Middle" fallacy. The middle term ("musicians") is not distributed in the premises, leading to an invalid conclusion despite the premises being true.

Explanation

The argument commits the "Undistributed Middle" fallacy. The middle term ("musicians") is not distributed in the premises, leading to an invalid conclusion despite the premises being true.
Click to rate:

Similar Questions