QuestionJune 9, 2025

How did the stable arrangement of the solar system result from a "natural sieve," according to Dawkins in The Blind Watchmaker? the nearer a satellite is to the sun , the faster it must travel God arranged the planets so that they would be stable logic tells us it is natural, but it is not known how it works heat forming through friction generates natural propulsion

How did the stable arrangement of the solar system result from a "natural sieve," according to Dawkins in The Blind Watchmaker? the nearer a satellite is to the sun , the faster it must travel God arranged the planets so that they would be stable logic tells us it is natural, but it is not known how it works heat forming through friction generates natural propulsion
How did the stable arrangement of the solar system result from a "natural sieve,"
according to Dawkins in The Blind Watchmaker?
the nearer a satellite is to the sun , the faster it must travel
God arranged the planets so that they would be stable
logic tells us it is natural, but it is not known how it works
heat forming through friction generates natural propulsion

Solution
4.7(281 votes)

Answer

Dawkins suggests the stable arrangement resulted from a natural selection process, where unstable orbits were naturally eliminated, leaving stable ones. Explanation 1. Identify the Concept Dawkins describes the solar system's stable arrangement as a result of natural selection processes, akin to a "natural sieve." 2. Explain the Mechanism The concept implies that planets and satellites that did not have stable orbits were naturally eliminated over time, leaving only those with stable configurations. 3. Clarify the Role of Speed The statement "the nearer a satellite is to the sun, the faster it must travel" aligns with **Kepler's laws**, which dictate orbital speeds based on distance from the sun. 4. Dismiss Incorrect Options The idea of God arranging planets contradicts Dawkins' naturalistic explanation. Friction generating propulsion is unrelated to orbital stability.

Explanation

1. Identify the Concept<br /> Dawkins describes the solar system's stable arrangement as a result of natural selection processes, akin to a "natural sieve."<br /><br />2. Explain the Mechanism<br /> The concept implies that planets and satellites that did not have stable orbits were naturally eliminated over time, leaving only those with stable configurations.<br /><br />3. Clarify the Role of Speed<br /> The statement "the nearer a satellite is to the sun, the faster it must travel" aligns with **Kepler's laws**, which dictate orbital speeds based on distance from the sun.<br /><br />4. Dismiss Incorrect Options<br /> The idea of God arranging planets contradicts Dawkins' naturalistic explanation. Friction generating propulsion is unrelated to orbital stability.
Click to rate:

Similar Questions